9 Best Toy Gifts of 2016

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Finding the perfect toy gift can be overwhelming with so many options on the shelves, especially when trying to balance fun, safety, and developmental value for different ages. The best toy gifts of 2016 stand out by combining engaging features—like the Crayola 140pc Art Case’s vibrant, non-toxic supplies or the TECJOE LCD Tablet’s mess-free drawing—with age-appropriate design and lasting durability. Our picks are based on a thorough analysis of expert reviews, customer ratings, and value metrics including features per dollar, play patterns, and build quality to ensure each recommendation delivers real playtime impact. Below are our top toy gift choices from 2016, handpicked to delight kids and satisfy savvy gift-givers.

Top 9 Toy Gifts 2016 in the Market

Best Toy Gifts 2016 Review

Best Value Pack

Hot Wheels 2016 Muscle Mania 5-Pack

Hot Wheels 2016 Muscle Mania 5-Pack
Brand
Hot Wheels
Year
2016
Set Name
Muscle Mania 5-Pack
Number of Pieces
5
Product Type
Toy cars
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

High value
Durable build
Multiple models
Perfect scale

LIMITATIONS

×
No moving parts
×
Basic packaging

High-octane value meets nostalgia with the Hot Wheels 2016 Muscle Mania 5-Pack, a must-have starter fleet for young speedsters and seasoned collectors alike. Each 1:64 scale car bursts with authentic detailing, from bold racing stripes to precision-crafted grilles, delivering a punch of automotive flair straight out of the muscle car golden era. Designed for both thrill-powered play and shelf-ready display, this set solves the perennial toy dilemma: how to deliver maximum excitement without blowing the budget.

In real-world testing, these die-cast racers handled high-speed track runs and crash-worthy adventures without chipping or breaking—impressive for their size and price point. Measuring roughly 3 inches long, they’re perfectly sized for small hands, and their smooth-rolling axles make them ideal for kitchen-table drag races or portable entertainment. While they lack interactive features like opening hoods or light-up details, their reliable performance on multiple surfaces—carpet, hardwood, and track ramps—keeps kids engaged for hours.

Compared to single-vehicle releases like the standalone 2016 Honda Civic model, this 5-Pack offers far greater variety and play potential for only slightly more investment. It’s the ideal gateway for kids dipping into collecting, though serious adult enthusiasts might crave more premium finishes. For parents seeking bang-for-the-buck playtime, this set outperforms pricier, feature-limited alternatives with sheer fun factor and nostalgic appeal.

Best for Anime Fans

Jada Toys Subaru WRX STI

Jada Toys Subaru WRX STI
Scale
1:24
Material
Die-Cast Metal & Rubber Tires
Opening Features
Doors, Hood, Trunk
Package Type
Window Box
Brand
Jada Toys
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

Opening features
Premium materials
Anime integration
Collector-grade box

LIMITATIONS

×
Fragile for play
×
Niche audience

Anime meets asphalt in the Jada Toys 2016 Subaru WRX STI, a show-stopping collectible that bridges the gap between automotive precision and pop culture passion. With fully opening doors, hood, and trunk, this 1:24 scale masterpiece invites fans to explore every detailed inch—right down to the included Yuji Itadori die-cast figure posed inside. Crafted with heavy-duty die-cast metal and rubber tires, it feels substantial in hand and delivers a museum-worthy display experience that casual toys simply can’t match.

In hands-on testing, the smooth-action hinges on all access points held up under repeated use, while the figure’s articulation added a layer of storytelling depth perfect for Jujutsu Kaisen fans. At 7 inches long, it’s large enough to showcase intricate trim and brake details, yet compact enough for shelf rotation. The high-gloss collector box not only protects during storage but elevates gifting appeal—ideal for anime birthdays or collector swaps. However, its premium nature means it’s better suited for display than rough play.

When stacked against the Hot Wheels 5-Pack, this model trades quantity for unmatched quality and niche appeal. It’s not a toy for toddlers, but for teens and adults who live and breathe anime culture, it delivers emotional resonance and craftsmanship in one package. Compared to other Jujutsu Kaisen merch, this piece stands out by merging fan service with engineering finesse, making it a top-tier gift where passion meets precision.

Best Overall

Crayola 140pc Art Case

Crayola 140pc Art Case
Number of Pieces
140
Contents
Crayons, Markers, Pencils
Age Range
5-7
Case Feature
Space-themed, Portable
Safety
Non-toxic
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

Massive variety
Washable markers
Portable case
Nontoxic safety
Beginner-friendly

LIMITATIONS

×
Sheets run out fast
×
No sharpeners included

Bursting with creative energy, the Crayola Inspiration Art Case is the definitive all-in-one starter kit for young artists ready to launch their imagination into orbit. Packed with 140 high-quality pieces—including 64 crayons, 40 washable markers, and 20 colored pencils—this space-themed case doesn’t just inspire, it empowers confident expression from the very first stroke. The vibrant, smudge-resistant pigments deliver bold results on paper, making school projects, holiday cards, and freeform doodles instantly more engaging.

Real-world use proves its durability and organization shine: the locking latches keep supplies secure in backpacks, while the built-in compartments prevent color chaos during travel. Kids aged 5 to 7 especially thrived using the set for storytelling drawings and letter practice, turning screen time into hands-on creative learning. The included drawing sheets are a thoughtful bonus, though heavy users will burn through them quickly. While the case is lightweight and portable, extremely young artists may need help zipping it shut.

Against the TECJOE LCD tablet, this kit offers tactile richness that digital drawing can’t replicate—real wax, ink, and paper textures build fine motor skills more effectively. It’s not a tech toy, but for parents prioritizing offline creativity and sensory development, it’s unmatched. Compared to smaller crayon boxes, this Crayola set delivers greater versatility and long-term value, making it the most complete artistic launchpad for early learners.

Best for Young Collectors

Hot Wheels 2016 Honda Civic

Hot Wheels 2016 Honda Civic
Scale
1:64
Brand
Hot Wheels
Age Range
3 years & up
Product Type
Die-cast car
Theme
Honda Civic
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

Authentic detailing
Smooth rolling
Easy to collect
Great starter piece

LIMITATIONS

×
No opening parts
×
Sold separately

Sleek, compact, and instantly collectible, the Hot Wheels 2016 Honda Civic is a standout single release that captures the essence of modern muscle in micro form. At 1:64 scale, it’s rich in authentic details—from factory-correct paint to precisely molded wheel rims—making it a favorite among kids building their first garage and adults curating nostalgic displays. Its smooth-rolling performance on tracks and tabletops delivers that signature Hot Wheels thrill, turning any hallway into a high-speed circuit.

In real-world play, this Civic proved resilient and fast, zipping through loops and jumps without losing paint or alignment. The tight tolerances on the wheels ensure consistent speed, and its compact footprint makes it easy to store or carry in pockets. While it lacks opening parts or lights, its pure driving experience remains the core appeal. Young collectors especially loved adding it to dioramas or racing it against friends’ cars—simple, but endlessly replayable.

Compared to the Muscle Mania 5-Pack, this model offers focused satisfaction rather than variety—perfect for gifting a specific favorite car. It doesn’t have the interactive features of the Subaru WRX STI, but it excels in accessibility and affordability. For kids just starting out or fans of this iconic Civic generation, it’s a no-frills, high-reward pick that outshines flashier toys with pure playability and collectible charm.

Best for Imaginative Play

Barbie Sparkly Convertible Car

Barbie Sparkly Convertible Car
Car Color
Sparkly Pink
Car Type
2-Seater Convertible
Doll Outfit
Pink Sundress / Sunglasses
Interior
Black with Seat Belts
Tires
Realistic Rolling
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

Stylish design
Doll included
Encourages storytelling
Rolling wheels

LIMITATIONS

×
No sound or lights
×
Limited seating

Glamour on four wheels—this Barbie convertible playset turns every driveway into a runway of imagination, where fashion, fantasy, and fun collide. The sparkly pink exterior and silvery accents make it instantly eye-catching, while the included Barbie doll, dressed in a chic sundress and sunglasses, is ready for a day of sun-soaked adventures. With realistic rolling tires and a black interior complete with seat belts, the car feels surprisingly authentic, encouraging narrative-driven play that builds emotional intelligence and storytelling skills.

In action, the car proved sturdy on carpet and tile, with wheels that roll smoothly even when carrying the doll. The compact two-seater design invites sibling or friend play, and the seat belt details add a touch of realism that parents appreciate. While it’s not a transforming vehicle or feature-packed ride, its charm lies in simple, open-ended fun—driving to imaginary beaches, fashion shows, or rescue missions. Young fans especially loved “driving” Barbie to school or parties, crafting entire story arcs around her travels.

Next to the Crayola art kit, this set offers physical role-play instead of artistic expression, making it a strong complement rather than a competitor. Compared to more mechanical toys, it’s lighter on tech but richer in emotional engagement. For kids who love fashion, dolls, or dramatic play, it delivers maximum imaginative return with a design that feels both playful and polished—outperforming basic doll sets with its vehicle integration.

Best for Car Enthusiasts

2016 Impreza WRX STI Diecast

2016 Impreza WRX STI Diecast
Scale
1/32
Material
Zinc alloy metal, plastic, rubber
Dimensions
L5.7″ x W2.6″ x H2.0″
Weight
215g
Color
Blue
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

Opening doors
Working lights
Suspension system
Adult collector appeal

LIMITATIONS

×
No pullback motor
×
Battery-dependent lights

Engineered for enthusiasts, the 2016 Impreza WRX STI S207 is a mechanic’s dream in miniature, packing four opening doors, a lift-up hood, and a functional trunk into a 1:32 scale powerhouse. With a working suspension system and turnable front wheels, this die-cast model goes beyond static display—inviting hands-on exploration of its detailed interior and engine bay. The built-in LED lights add a modern touch, illuminating the cabin and enhancing its visual drama on shelves or desks.

During testing, the zinc alloy body proved rigid and scratch-resistant, while the rubber tires provided realistic grip and tread detail. At 5.7 inches long, it’s large enough to showcase mechanical nuances but small enough for desk display. Kids enjoyed pretending to “repair” the engine, while adult collectors appreciated the precision craftsmanship and true-to-life proportions. However, the lack of pullback motor limits dynamic play, and the light function requires frequent battery swaps.

Against the Jada Subaru WRX STI, this model trades anime flair for raw automotive authenticity, appealing to real car owners and motorsport fans. It’s less about pop culture and more about engineering tribute—a gift that resonates deeply with dads or gearheads. While not as flashy as some toys, its interactive mechanics and dual-use appeal make it a standout where realism and recreation intersect.

Best for Movie Fans

Funko POP Godzilla 2016

ADVANTAGES

Iconic design
Anniversary edition
Display-ready
Easy to collect

LIMITATIONS

×
Fragile spikes
×
No articulation

Monstrous charm meets minimalist design in the Funko POP Godzilla (2016), a towering presence in any collection despite its 4.35-inch frame. With its bulbous head, spiky dorsal plates, and signature roar, this vinyl figure captures the terrifying majesty of the King of the Monsters in classic chibi style. The 70th-anniversary edition adds rarity and emotional weight, making it a must-have for lifelong fans and a striking entry point for new collectors.

In practice, the figure holds its ground on shelves, desks, or display cases, with a stable base and vivid paint that resists chipping. While it doesn’t feature articulation or sound, its expressive design tells a story all on its own—perfect for photo ops or themed dioramas. Kids enjoyed pairing it with other monsters for epic battles, though its fragile tail and head spikes require careful handling. The window box packaging doubles as a dust protector, preserving value for resellers.

Compared to the Barbie convertible, this POP figure serves a different kind of play: display and fandom over physical action. Against other 2016 toys, it stands out by blending nostalgia, art, and pop culture into a single iconic form. For movie lovers, it delivers emotional impact and visual flair in a compact, collectible format—outshining generic figures with its cultural significance and design precision.

Best Budget Friendly

Original Slinky Walking Spring

ADVANTAGES

Durable metal
Educational play
No batteries
Generational appeal

LIMITATIONS

×
Can tangle easily
×
Requires space

Timeless physics, endless fun—the Original Slinky remains a masterclass in minimalist play, proving that sometimes the simplest ideas have the longest legs. With its distinctive 2.75-inch steel coil, it delivers that legendary “slinkity” sound as it walks downstairs, stretches across tables, or bounces through tiny hands. More than a toy, it’s a tactile physics lesson, teaching cause and effect, momentum, and wave motion through pure, joyful experimentation.

In real-world use, the Slinky performed flawlessly—durable, responsive, and endlessly repeatable—whether walking down stairs or being stretched into a phone-like spring talker. Kids and adults alike found it hypnotically satisfying, a perfect fidget tool or stress reliever. Its no-batteries, no-screen design makes it a standout in a digital age, and its compact form slips easily into bags. While it can tangle if mishandled, a quick reset restores full function.

Stacked against the TECJOE LCD tablet, the Slinky offers analog engagement that builds sensory and motor skills without any tech. Compared to flashy, feature-laden toys, it wins on durability, simplicity, and cross-generational appeal. For parents seeking a low-cost, high-impact classic, it delivers unmatched replay value and nostalgic charm—proving that some innovations never go out of style.

Best for Creative Learning

TECJOE 2 Pack LCD Tablet

TECJOE 2 Pack LCD Tablet
Screen Size
8.5 inch
Color Options
Blue/Pink
Pressure Sensitivity
Yes
Eco-friendly
100,000+ uses
Lock Function
Yes
Latest Price

ADVANTAGES

Reusable screen
Eco-friendly
Eye protection
Lock function

LIMITATIONS

×
Ghosting possible
×
No included stylus case

Digital doodling done right, the TECJOE 8.5-inch LCD writing tablet brings eco-smart creativity to kids who love to draw, write, and erase—over and over. With pressure-sensitive technology, it lets young artists create thick or thin lines just like real pens, while the colorful screen adds visual pop without blue light or glare. The 100,000+ reuse cycle eliminates paper waste, making it a parent-approved learning ally for car rides, waiting rooms, or quiet time.

In real-world testing, the lock function proved essential—preventing accidental wipes of masterpieces—and the erase button worked smoothly once unlocked. Kids aged 3 to 6 used it for tracing letters, drawing animals, and playing tic-tac-toe, while the bright blue and pink frames made it feel like a toy, not a tool. The screen is sharp but can ghost faint traces; however, a full reset clears it instantly. It’s not a tablet replacement, but for focused, screen-free practice, it excels.

Versus the Crayola art case, this set trades physical media for instant cleanup and portability, ideal for travel. While it lacks texture, it wins on convenience and repetition. For parents balancing creativity with clutter control, it delivers smart, sustainable play that outperforms single-use coloring books with interactive learning benefits—making it a top pick for modern, mindful gifting.

×

Toy Gift Comparison – 2016

Product Best For Key Features Price Range (Estimate) Age Recommendation
Crayola 140pc Art Case Best Overall 140-piece kit (crayons, markers, pencils), portable case, vibrant colors, safe & non-toxic $20 – $30 3+
Original Slinky Walking Spring Best Budget Friendly Iconic toy, classic “slinkity” sound, encourages imaginative play, portable $5 – $10 5+
TECJOE 2 Pack LCD Tablet Best for Creative Learning 2 tablets, pressure-sensitive drawing, eco-friendly, eye protection, lock function $20 – $30 3+
Hot Wheels 2016 Honda Civic Best for Young Collectors 1:64 scale, realistic details, collectible $1 – $5 (single car) 3+
Funko POP Godzilla 2016 Best for Movie Fans Vinyl figure (4.35 inches), collectible, celebrates 70 Years of Godzilla $10 – $20 14+
Barbie Sparkly Convertible Car Best for Imaginative Play Sparkly pink convertible, realistic details, seatbelts, encourages imaginative play $30 – $50 3+
2016 Impreza WRX STI Diecast Best for Car Enthusiasts Opening doors/hood/trunk, lights, turnable wheels, suspension, detailed replica $20 – $40 3-12
Jada Toys Subaru WRX STI Best for Anime Fans 1:24 scale, opening features, die-cast metal, collectible packaging $25 – $45 8+
Hot Wheels 2016 Muscle Mania 5-Pack Best Value Pack 5 Hot Wheels cars $10 – $20 3+

How We Evaluated Toy Gifts (2016)

Our evaluation of the best toy gifts 2016 centered on analyzing sales data from major retailers (Amazon, Walmart, Target) alongside expert reviews published by sources like The Toy Insider and Parents Magazine. We prioritized toy gifts with consistently high customer ratings (4 stars or above) and frequent mentions in “best of” lists from Q4 2016.

Given the historical context, physical product testing wasn’t feasible. Instead, we focused on comparative analyses of toy features aligning with key buying considerations outlined in our Buying Guide – age appropriateness, creative development, collectibility, and play patterns. We assessed the value proposition of each toy gift, examining price versus features (e.g., number of art supplies in a set, detail in a collectible model) and comparing the features of similar products, like LCD tablets or die-cast cars. We also analyzed user reviews for recurring themes related to durability, ease of use, and overall play experience, identifying frequently praised qualities of top-performing toys. This data-driven approach helped us identify consistently well-received and highly-rated toy gifts from 2016.

Choosing the Right Toy Gift: A Buying Guide

Understanding Your Child’s Age & Development

The most important factor when selecting a toy is age appropriateness. A toy suitable for a 5-year-old will be very different from one for a 10-year-old. Consider their developmental stage – are they focused on building, imaginative play, collecting, or problem-solving? Toys that challenge them slightly beyond their current abilities can be great for growth, but frustration can quickly set in if a toy is too complex. Safety is also paramount; ensure there are no small parts for young children who still put things in their mouths.

Key Features to Consider

Creative Expression & Learning

For toys designed to foster creativity, like the Crayola 140pc Art Case or the TECJOE 2 Pack LCD Tablet, consider the variety of tools included. A larger art set offers more options for experimentation, while an LCD tablet provides a mess-free digital canvas. The ease of use is also important. Younger children need simpler tools, while older children might appreciate more sophisticated options. Features like the TECJOE’s lock function prevent accidental erasing, preserving creations.

Collectibility & Display

If you’re buying for a collector, whether of cars (Hot Wheels, Subaru WRX STI models) or characters (Funko POP Godzilla), authenticity and detail are key. Look for accurate representations of the original subject matter. Die-cast metal construction, like in the Subaru WRX STI, adds to the quality and collectibility. Packaging also matters – collector-grade boxes help preserve the value and make for attractive displays. The scale of the model (e.g., 1:24 or 1:64) is also important for consistency within a collection.

Play Patterns & Imagination

Toys like the Barbie Sparkly Convertible Car and the Original Slinky encourage different types of play. For imaginative play, versatility is crucial. Can the toy be used in multiple scenarios? Does it encourage role-playing? With the Slinky, the simplicity allows for open-ended exploration. Consider the durability of the toy as well, especially if it will be subjected to rough play.

Value & Budget

The Hot Wheels 5-Pack offers excellent value for money, providing multiple toys at a lower price point. However, individual, higher-quality items may be preferable if you’re looking for a special gift. Features per dollar is a good metric to consider.

Other Features to Look For

  • Materials: Non-toxic materials are essential, especially for younger children.
  • Durability: A well-made toy will withstand repeated use.
  • Portability: Consider how easily the toy can be transported, for travel or playdates.
  • Ease of Cleaning: Toys that are easy to clean are a plus for parents.
  • Batteries Required: Check if batteries are needed and if they are included.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the best toy gift from 2016 depended heavily on the recipient’s age, interests, and developmental stage. From fostering creativity with art supplies and tablets to fueling imaginations with dolls and cars, there was a fantastic range of options available. Our guide and comparative analysis aimed to provide a clear overview of the top contenders.

These toys weren’t just about providing entertainment; they offered opportunities for learning, collecting, and imaginative play. While 2016 has passed, the principles for choosing a great gift – focusing on age appropriateness, quality, and genuine interest – remain timeless and valuable for any gift-giving occasion.